The 3d DCA overturned the quashal of a DMV driver's license suspension in Fla DMV v. Jones, here's the link. The Department (in a hearing before a non-lawyer, department employee) apparently suspended the license based only on the officer's arrest report. The issue was probably cause for the stop, and the appeal was over whether the lower court had reviewed the statements in the report using a "subjective" versus "objective" test.
But the real issue is that people's licenses are being suspended based only on documentary evidence without the right to confront. The idea that these arrest reports are self-documenting and can be introduced without the sworn testimony of the officer (absent one of the various exceptions to hearsay, etc.) flies in the face of any kind of democratic justice.
Think about it: an administrative agency suspends your license based on a document, then gives you a "hearing" in front of one of its employees - who has no training in the law -- and then rests its case on the document, with no meaningful opportunity to challenge the contents of the document. In other words, in any meaningful way, the arresting officer IS the sheriff, judge, jury and executioner (since the officer siezes the license), because there is no meaningful way to challenge the officer's action.
Good bye justice and freedom. Hello Gulag.
Use the largest online attorney directory to quickly find detailed profiles of Florida lawyers and law firms in your area.
Chủ Nhật, 11 tháng 6, 2006
Đăng ký:
Đăng Nhận xét (Atom)
Bài đăng phổ biến
-
Here's an interesting opinion from Magistrate Judge Torres awarding defendants attorney's fees for opposing a copyright infringemen...
-
Hi kids, the heat is on and the bunker denizens are leading the way with their official 3d DCA summer pickle ball league -- judicial gentle...
-
Having been disappointed by several recent 11th Circuit opinions, I am pleased to see here a straightforward application of the "econo...
-
That old W.C. Fields line is ringing in my head, as the wind kicks up and rip tides batter the coast. I have to be honest, with the emerging...
-
Greenberg Traurig says it's not really necessary; Judge Middlebrooks says it is probably a good idea: In response, Plaintiff argues, in...
-
Shuster & Saben Defeats US Bank & Douglas Zahm PA in Foreclosure Appeal In 2011, firm attorney Richard Shuster obtained the dis...
-
Federal Rule Violation If you have been charged with USCA0024 FEDERAL RULE VIOLATION you can call a Defense Attorney Tampa at 1-877-793-9290...
-
Sheesh, does anyone have any news of any interest? Does it count that I saw Ervin rockin' some hard-core aviators outside the courthous...
-
Now that's a headline I thought I'd never write. Actually, it's a very unfortunate case involving a tourist who died riding a Ba...
-
Many of us have hired these guys as experts over the years, and I see the firm is merging and changing its name : South Florida's eight...
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét