Use the largest online attorney directory to quickly find detailed profiles of Florida lawyers and law firms in your area.
Thứ Ba, 1 tháng 12, 2009
Glenn Garvin, Late and Wrong
Glenn Garvin's column today presents a case study in what is wrong with op-eds in local newspapers.
First, he's picked a topic with no local angle -- the trial of KSM in New York.
Being a national story, this topic has been discussed at length in newspapers and blogs and on TV ever since Attorney General Holder made the announcement two weeks ago.
Indeed, I covered it a week back on November 24.
So, if you are going to approach a topic that is several media-cycles old and which has already been the subject of tremendous debate and analysis by every major national columnist in this country, you need to bring something new to the table.
Needless to say, Garvin fails.
Instead, Garvin offers a deeply flawed and inaccurate understanding of how the criminal justice system works, with absolutely no reference to the successful terrorist prosecutions that have occured in this country, such as John Walker Lindh, Richard Reid, Zacarias Moussaoui, Ali al-Marri, Jose Padilla -- all tried under the Bush Administration btw.
Garvin's gloom and doom and fear-based arguments are too silly to get into, and have already been addressed dozens of times by knowledgeable lawyers such as former Bush AGs Jim Comey and Jack Goldsmith.
The larger point has to do with the newspaper business. If you are that late to a story, you have to approach it like Time Magazine, The Nation, or National Review -- deliver some analysis, synthesis, commentary that reflects a point of view or which has been lacking in the day-to-day coverage thus far.
Can anyone reading Garvin's column today -- including his editors -- say with a straight face that Garvin has added something (anything?) meaningful to the discussion?
Đăng ký:
Đăng Nhận xét (Atom)
Bài đăng phổ biến
-
That old W.C. Fields line is ringing in my head, as the wind kicks up and rip tides batter the coast. I have to be honest, with the emerging...
-
Now that's a headline I thought I'd never write. Actually, it's a very unfortunate case involving a tourist who died riding a Ba...
-
Many of us have hired these guys as experts over the years, and I see the firm is merging and changing its name : South Florida's eight...
-
Federal Rule Violation If you have been charged with USCA0024 FEDERAL RULE VIOLATION you can call a Defense Attorney Tampa at 1-877-793-9290...
-
Sheesh, does anyone have any news of any interest? Does it count that I saw Ervin rockin' some hard-core aviators outside the courthous...
-
That's the lede in this solid article on South Florida lawyers starting to make deals again, by the always intrepid Julie Kay: Jim Meye...
-
Aggravated Stalking Felony If you have been charged with ASSA6001 AGGRAVATED STALKING you can c all a Defense Attorney Tampa at 1-877-793-92...
-
Boy, this is the story that keeps on giving. I really love the way Carvalho has handled the whole emails to his lover thing, because it s...
-
Spencer Aronfeld Spencer Aronfeld Spencer Aronfeld Spencer Aronfeld Gin Gibsons sexy Israelis Hitler Alfred E. Neumann windsurfing Bo Derek ...
-
Several in-the-know readers have passed along an incendiary anonymous memo making the rounds among administrators and trustees regarding fin...
Không có nhận xét nào:
Đăng nhận xét